Hi! It's been a while, and I'm back with Marx. For those of you who don't know him, his picture in below. (TA-DAH!)

Yup, so this is Karl Marx. He was a great person with great ideas. Although Marx is showing a "peace" sign in this picture, his ideas of Communism had nevertheless brought bloodshed, revolutions, and even poverty to many parts of the world. But of course we could not blame Marx for those sufferings, for all he did was just think and write.

Anyhow, I came across a few words in Marx's writing which I think is interesting and worth to share. Marx wrote, "it is not the consciousness of men that determines their being, but, on the contrary, their social being that determines their consciousness".

The key word here is consciousness. According to my Oxford dictionary, consciousness means:

1. the state of being able to use your senses and mental power to understand what is happening.

2. the state of being aware of something.

3. the ideas and opinions of a person or group.

In Thai, consciousness simply means "sa-ti". So what Marx is saying, I believe, is that how we think, act, and are today is shaped by our society. According to this understand, what music I like to listen to, what clothes I like to wear, and what food I like to eat are not actually decided by me. In fact they are decided by what I life-experience I had, what education I received, and even what T.V programme I've watched.

Well, that kind of sum up my understanding of Marx's quote. Do you agree with me or have anything to add? If you agree with my interpretation of Marx, then do you agree with what Marx is saying?

Disagreements are also welcome. For arguing and exchanging of ideas are the most effective ways to learn. Cheers!

Views: 646

Add a Comment

You need to be a member of Funky English to add comments!

Join Funky English

Comment by Slavica on October 23, 2012 at 20:10

I agree:D

Comment by Blue Peace on October 23, 2012 at 20:05

Hehe, your writing reminds me of philosophy in my first year. I remebered that we had to demonstrate that saying is true ("it is not the consciousness of men that determines their being, but, on the contrary, their social being that determines their consciousness").

Marx is very famous of philosophy. In my country, Marxism-Leninism is taught in all universities. I do agree with what Marx saying. :D


Teacher
Comment by English Teacher Jamie on October 23, 2012 at 19:34

Nice to see you again Tyrant! How is life?

This is an interesting blog. I agree that we are shaped by our society, our education and our family. I think our society today has changed with the invention of the Internet. People have more access to education, different opinions and different cultures. In the future people might be less concerned with national identities and more concerned with being a citizen of the world. 

Forum

Fed up! 17 Replies

Started by English Teacher Jamie in Phrasal Verbs. Last reply by English Teacher Jamie 2 hours ago.

Meh! 15 Replies

Started by English Teacher Jamie in English Slang. Last reply by Tammy 6 hours ago.

Past Continuous Tense - What Were You Doing When...? 20 Replies

Started by English Teacher Jamie in Talk about.... Last reply by Vi ai anh chet 17 hours ago.

Present Simple Tense - Daily Routine 37 Replies

Started by English Teacher Jamie in Talk about.... Last reply by poshkin kurdy 17 hours ago.

Cost an arm and a leg! 60 Replies

Started by English Teacher Jamie in English Idioms. Last reply by vero (陈 菲玉) yesterday.

Calm down! 19 Replies

Started by English Teacher Jamie in Phrasal Verbs. Last reply by coco yesterday.

The Amazing Potato! 19 Replies

Started by English Teacher Jamie in Talk about.... Last reply by vero (陈 菲玉) yesterday.

Life begins at forty ! 17 Replies

Started by Amr Tom in Talk about.... Last reply by vero (陈 菲玉) yesterday.

Introduce yourself to Funky English here! 355 Replies

Started by English Teacher Jamie in Introduction. Last reply by English Teacher Jamie on Monday.

Buddy! 11 Replies

Started by English Teacher Jamie in English Slang. Last reply by coco on Sunday.

© 2013   Created by English Teacher Jamie.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service